Presuppositional Baggage and the Hermeneutics of Humility


God is worth his word being studied well. In fact, the words of God are immanently crucial for believers and unbelievers alike. Of course arriving at the meaning of those words is a daunting task; nonetheless, it is a task we must engage in. In contemplating this serious endeavor, the gravity should lead to what might be called a hermeneutic of humility. Several applicable considerations can help in cultivating such a posture.

Context Context Pretext

Assigning meaning in the 21st century to the sacred text written millennia ago is not to be taken lightly. There are cultural, linguistic, historical, philosophical, spiritual, and personal barriers that must be considered. In other words, understanding the text in light of its original language, culture, and historical setting, and then applying that in today’s setting is hard work. Too often pastors and theologians give lip service to the chief hermeneutical principal of taking a passage in context only to make the context fit within their own pretext of theological or philosophical bias. Take a breath. Everybody brings presuppositional baggage as they seek to read and interpret Scripture. So, acknowledge it, take an interpretive step back, and engage thoughtfully.

Theology, History, and oh yeah…the Spirit

Theology and church history are useful, but the Spirit is necessary. Before theological systems and the history that developed with the passage of time, believers had the oral heritage of scripture along with inspired circulating letters/works as well as the power of the indwelling Spirit. Often today the role of the spirit in understanding and interpreting the text is relegated to merely agreeing with those in your own circle. Being dependent on and conscious of the Spirit is not mysticism, but neither is it merely compliance to “walk the denominational line.”

Celebrity Pastors are not Interpretive Mediators

Protestants tout the priesthood of all believers only to establish interpretive intermediaries in the form of prominent pastors. This isn’t a railing against the God-ordained role or leadership of the pastor, but it is a call for all believers to hold the meaning of Scripture as it is over the meaning of Scripture as it is explained by mortal men. Sermons, blogs, commentaries, study Bibles, and books from honorable pastors are all helpful tools, but they are not the final authority on biblical interpretation.

The Elephant in the Process

Biblical inerrancy, infallibility, and sufficiency are a part of the evangelical checklist. Add to that a call for exposition and faithfulness to the text. But we ourselves are the elephant in the process. We are more prone to herald what D.A. Carson says Scripture is saying than to wrestle all night for the blessing of the honeycomb to our souls. We tend to blindly approach the text with our denominational slant without even a thought that perhaps…just perhaps…we are wrong. The result is an arrogant posture that a John Mellencamp song captures.

Handing out verses of scripture like we wrote it down ourselves…

This is not a call to be timid in proclaiming the authority of Scripture, but to realize that we are not that authority. Actually, a posture of humility rather than arrogance better represents a healthy respect for the word of God. Being aware of the degree that context and the role of the Spirit are neglected while the perspective of a favorite pastor and our own biases take the lead can help us cultivate humility. That humility actually produces an interpretive posture where spiritual people can understand and communicate spiritual things to others who are spiritual (1 Corinthians 2:10–13).

Chris Dunn
Latest posts by Chris Dunn (see all)
Comments 2
  1. Thanks for reading and engaging. While your point is taken to heart, I disagree. Theology is merely the pursuit of knowing God as well as we can through His primary means of revelation: scripture. I grant that one’s intellect can certainly get in the way; however, I also hold that God created us in His image as people with minds and commanded us to love Him with all our “heart, mind, soul, and strength.” I don’t believe theology is a joke, but I must confess I sometimes find myself laughing at theologians who take themselves a bit too seriously.

  2. What is symbiosis? Certainly that’s a mystery to science, and thus a complete mystery to religion. It’s a complete mystery to religion thus it’s a mystery to science. Coldplay came out with a song a few years back called “clocks”. In the song it asks ” are you a part of the cure, or are you part of the disease” , it then responds “you are, you are” . Leave it to music to be terrific theology. Theology is like a badly written auto repair manual in comparison and all of it leads to a doxology of the cranium. Maybe theology is for the deeply handicapped, smart folk, unaware their strength , their intellect, is their weakness. Theology is a joke.

Comments are closed.

Your 100 Day Prayer: Day 3 – Good Out of Evil

Your 100 Day Prayer: Day 3 – Good Out of Evil

God is worth his word being studied well

Charles Spurgeon’s “Morning and Evening” – January 3, Evening

Charles Spurgeon’s “Morning and Evening” – January 3, Evening

God is worth his word being studied well